Skills Legal Research and Reasoning

at Maastricht University

Join course
371
Discussion
Documents
Flashcards
Does anyone know how to refer Dutch case law into footnotes according to OSCOLA? I only came this far: [1954] HR 378 NJ But not sure whether this is OSCOLA, since the oxford handbook only deals with UK and international case law
https://www.law.ox.ac.uk/sites/files/oxlaw/oscola_4th_edn_hart_2012quickreferenceguide.pdf - this is the quick guide https://www.law.ox.ac.uk/sites/files/oxlaw/oscola_4th_edn_hart_2012.pdf - this is the full guide. I always use these, much better and straight-forward explained than in the book we used for skills. This is what Oscola says: "Cite cases from other jurisdictions as they are cited in their own jurisdiction, but with minimal punctuation. If the name of the law report series cited does not itself indicate the court, and the identity of the court is not obvious from the context, you should also give this in either full or short form in brackets at the end of the citation. When citing a decision of the highest court of a US state, the abbreviation of the name of the state suffices." page 32 of the Full Guide
Does maybe anyone has any ideas according to resit assignment? what type of the fallacy?
View 7 more comments
i think 34 is possible too. yeah
32(self-defence) is about the attack and 34 is about the danger (necessity)
does anyone know which article should we use for resit assignment ?
View 1 more comment
do you think could it be 212?
i meant 212 sorry mistake
Anyone have any examples of good research questions for skills 1 resit ?
What are the criminal liability requirements in Germany?
Guys does anybody understand the format of task 6...? not sure how or what to write exactly
What is the legal issue? I'm torn between are they liable or are they guilty of abandonment?
there are two legal issues. One is the liability and the other is the committed act
Does anybody understand how to chose/decide if its C1A or C1AA etc u kno?
View 6 more comments
Cc: If someone abandons him in a helpless situation although he has him in custody and thereby exposes him to a danger of death. Cd: If someone abandons him in a helpless situation although he has him in custody and thereby exposes him to a serious health damage. two separate conditions
what is the lq for 221 (1) ?
what is the conclusion of the case? are the boys | boardmembers liable?
All the boys and board members are liable for ella’s death. But should we also see if they are liable for celia’s psychic illness, because they were only arrested when ella was found and earlier not for celia?...
do we need to identify only 1 fallacy or all 3 in the case, if only 1 how do we choose which one?
View 2 more comments
tu quoque
thanks because i was not sure since i also heard people mentioning bandwagon
What are the legal rules of assignment II?
View 18 more comments
how did you guys add the subsections 2 and 3 to subsection 1? are you allowed to just add that with the others or not? can someone write down how they wrote it in their assignment?
what fallacy of the text did you guys use and what was the correct fallacy to apply? i heard a lot about tu queqou but for which sentence in the text did you guys use that for?
also are you guys doing section 1 or section 2 for art 25
2
Do we need to write why we think this is the main legal issue and to apply the fallacy to the text or it’s sufficient just to state it?
View 5 more comments
for which one did you use that for what sentence in the text ?
was that for the one with 'come on robert'?
Anyone doing resit assignment 2 and know the rules applicable to the case ?
View 6 more comments
Thanks!
Guys quick question, how did you apply the rule analysis on article 32? Just don't understand how you incorporated the definition of necessary defence? As like C2 or ?
Anyone have any examples of good research questions for skills 1 resit ?
Does anyone have an example of a legal research question writing? Especially to illustrate the use of OSCOLA, ELS style
View 1 more comment
Volume with civil code
Yeah, volume IV